The SA Politics Thread

Anything goes here.. :) Now with Beer Garden for our smoking patrons.
Message
Author
User avatar
Llessur2002
Legendary Member!
Posts: 1456
Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:59 pm
Location: West Croydon
Has thanked: 423 times
Been thanked: 666 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1066 Post by Llessur2002 » Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:55 pm

rev wrote:
Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:24 pm
To fill up a car, say 50 litres, can range from $59 @ $1.19/L to $84 @ $1.69/L.

Using Uber, from Henley Beach it will cost $24-$32 per trip. $48 a day. $240 a week minimum.
Blair Athol to the CBD - $20-$27. $40 a day. $200 a week minimum.
Brompton to the CBD - $14-$19. $28 a day. $140 a week minimum.
Mile End to the CBD - $12-$17. $24 a day. $120 a week minimum.

Five days a week.

You don't have a car, or access to the only car you have. So you now have to factor in more spending on Uber to get around.

That tank of fuel for between $59 and $84 a week, will get you a lot further for less money then Uber will.
Let's say that your average weekly spend on fuel is $70 a week averaged out for the whole year. That's $3,640 for the year on fuel.
$120 a week Mile End to CBD, is $6,240 a year. Factor in Uber spending of a couple thousand more since you've given up your car.

Lets factor in registration for the year for your car. $600-$800.
Insurance, $500-800.
Servicing every six months, another $500-600 unless you go to a cheap nasty mechanic.

You are still better off financially with your own car, then giving it up for Uber or a taxi.
Not only that, but you are better off because you have more flexibility and convenience available to you.

You guys might have that alternative mindset, alternative living and all that, but the majority of people don't share that. That's why the taxi hasn't replaced mass personal vehicle ownership. And that's why Uber and others wont either.
Don't forget to factor in the depreciation of the car. I would suspect the average family car depreciates by around $10,000-$15,000 over a five year period - $2000-$3000 per year on average (although in reality a larger chunk of that will happen in the first year of ownership and tail off as the car gets older).

rev
Super Size Scraper Poster!
Posts: 3859
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 12:14 pm
Has thanked: 246 times
Been thanked: 349 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1067 Post by rev » Thu Aug 08, 2019 3:10 pm

Nathan wrote:
Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:39 pm
rev wrote:
Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:24 pm
To fill up a car, say 50 litres, can range from $59 @ $1.19/L to $84 @ $1.69/L.

Using Uber, from Henley Beach it will cost $24-$32 per trip. $48 a day. $240 a week minimum.
Blair Athol to the CBD - $20-$27. $40 a day. $200 a week minimum.
Brompton to the CBD - $14-$19. $28 a day. $140 a week minimum.
Mile End to the CBD - $12-$17. $24 a day. $120 a week minimum.

Five days a week.

You don't have a car, or access to the only car you have. So you now have to factor in more spending on Uber to get around.

That tank of fuel for between $59 and $84 a week, will get you a lot further for less money then Uber will.
Let's say that your average weekly spend on fuel is $70 a week averaged out for the whole year. That's $3,640 for the year on fuel.
$120 a week Mile End to CBD, is $6,240 a year. Factor in Uber spending of a couple thousand more since you've given up your car.

Lets factor in registration for the year for your car. $600-$800.
Insurance, $500-800.
Servicing every six months, another $500-600 unless you go to a cheap nasty mechanic.

You are still better off financially with your own car, then giving it up for Uber or a taxi.
Not only that, but you are better off because you have more flexibility and convenience available to you.

You guys might have that alternative mindset, alternative living and all that, but the majority of people don't share that. That's why the taxi hasn't replaced mass personal vehicle ownership. And that's why Uber and others wont either.
No one is suggested using an Uber/Taxi every day. Of course that doesn't stack up. The argument is for people who use the additional car more sparingly (or could adapt to using it more sparingly), then it can be cheaper to use those services (and stop ignoring carshare services) instead of having that additional car sitting there and all the costs that involves.
Ok lets talk carshare.
https://www.goget.com.au/pricing/

Three plans. These are prices for a small hatchback, their cheapest.
GoStarter - $49 a year membership fee, and From $10.65/hr + $0.40/km, $87/day for a car. 1 Driver. Yearly membership.
GoOccasional - $12 a month membership fee, From $9.45/hr + $0.40/km $79/day. 2 Drivers. 6 month membership, then month to month.
GoFrequent - $30 a month membership fee, From $6.35/hr + $0.40/km $74/day. 4 Drivers. Month to Month membership.

150km is included in all plans.

Am I reading that correct?
Becauase it doesn't sound very economical.

CarNextDoor from $25/d..use it for the working week, $125.
Even for two days use, that's $50. You wouldn't spend even half of that on fuel in your own personal vehicle in two days.

On DriveMyCar, the cheapest I can find is $20/d.

The cheaper the car, the smaller the car.
The bigger the car, the more expensive. Same with age of the car.

It might be useful, when you're desperate to get somewhere once off, but it's not an economical or viable alternative to owning your own car.
The money you will spend on these cars, you may as well catch a bus, ride a bike, or walk, and save mots of that money to buy your own car.

rev
Super Size Scraper Poster!
Posts: 3859
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 12:14 pm
Has thanked: 246 times
Been thanked: 349 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1068 Post by rev » Thu Aug 08, 2019 3:12 pm

Llessur2002 wrote:
Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:55 pm
rev wrote:
Thu Aug 08, 2019 2:24 pm
To fill up a car, say 50 litres, can range from $59 @ $1.19/L to $84 @ $1.69/L.

Using Uber, from Henley Beach it will cost $24-$32 per trip. $48 a day. $240 a week minimum.
Blair Athol to the CBD - $20-$27. $40 a day. $200 a week minimum.
Brompton to the CBD - $14-$19. $28 a day. $140 a week minimum.
Mile End to the CBD - $12-$17. $24 a day. $120 a week minimum.

Five days a week.

You don't have a car, or access to the only car you have. So you now have to factor in more spending on Uber to get around.

That tank of fuel for between $59 and $84 a week, will get you a lot further for less money then Uber will.
Let's say that your average weekly spend on fuel is $70 a week averaged out for the whole year. That's $3,640 for the year on fuel.
$120 a week Mile End to CBD, is $6,240 a year. Factor in Uber spending of a couple thousand more since you've given up your car.

Lets factor in registration for the year for your car. $600-$800.
Insurance, $500-800.
Servicing every six months, another $500-600 unless you go to a cheap nasty mechanic.

You are still better off financially with your own car, then giving it up for Uber or a taxi.
Not only that, but you are better off because you have more flexibility and convenience available to you.

You guys might have that alternative mindset, alternative living and all that, but the majority of people don't share that. That's why the taxi hasn't replaced mass personal vehicle ownership. And that's why Uber and others wont either.
Don't forget to factor in the depreciation of the car. I would suspect the average family car depreciates by around $10,000-$15,000 over a five year period - $2000-$3000 per year on average (although in reality a larger chunk of that will happen in the first year of ownership and tail off as the car gets older).
That doesn't affect your running costs though. Insurance and registration don't go down for example, because the value of your car has gone down. Unless there's some insurance company that does that that is a well kept secret.

User avatar
Llessur2002
Legendary Member!
Posts: 1456
Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:59 pm
Location: West Croydon
Has thanked: 423 times
Been thanked: 666 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1069 Post by Llessur2002 » Thu Aug 08, 2019 3:21 pm

No, but if a car is kept solely for the purpose of commuting (which many second vehicles would be) then the depreciation of the car should be taken into account when comparing private vehicle use vs Uber etc. It is a cost which would not exist if the car was not owned.

rev
Super Size Scraper Poster!
Posts: 3859
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 12:14 pm
Has thanked: 246 times
Been thanked: 349 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1070 Post by rev » Thu Aug 15, 2019 9:54 am

Another pay rise for our politicians. $4687/year increase, the premier is taking home $9,000 extra a year.

The premier will now be paid $401,252
Backbenchers will be paid $200,626
Opposition leader, ministers, speaker of the house and upper house president are now on $351,096
Labor front benchers $250,000

The full list of what SA state politicians get paid;

Code: Select all

Basham	David	2018	HoA	Finniss	$200,626
Bedford	Frances	1997	HoA	Florey	$200,626
Bell	Troy	2014	HoA	Mt Gambier	$200,626
Bettison	Zoe	2012	HoA	Ramsey	$250,783
Bignell	Leon	2006	HoA	Mawson	$200,626
Bonaros	Connie	2018	LC		$200,626
Bourke	Emily	2018	HoA		$200,626
Boyer	Blair	2018	HoA	Wright	$200,626
Brock	Geoff	2009	HoA	Frome	$200,626
Brown	Michael 	2018	HoA	Playford	$236,739
Chapman	Vickie	2002	HoA	Bragg	$371,158
Close	Susan	2012	HoA	Port Adelaide	$321,002
Cook 	Nat	2014	HoA	Hurtle Vale	$250,783
Cowdrey	Matt	2018	HoA	Colton	$200,626
Cregan	Dan	2018	HoA	Kavel	$228,714
Darley	John	2007	LC		$200,626
Dawkins	John	1997	LC		$228,714
Duluk	Sam	2015	HoA	Waite	$234,732
Ellis	Fraser	2018	HoA	Narunnga	$200,626
Franks	Tammy	2010	LC		$200,626
Gardner	John	2010	HoA	Morialta	$351,096
Gee	Jon	2014	HoA	Taylor	$200,626
Habib	Carolyn	2018	HoA	Elder	$240,751
Hanson	Justin	2017	LC		$200,626
Harvey	Richard	2018	HoA	Newland	$200,626
Hildyard	Katrine	2014	HoA	Reynell	$250,783
Hood	Dennis	2014	LC		$228,714
Hughes	Eddie	2014	HoA	Giles	$250,783
Hunter	Ian	2006	LC		$220,689
Knoll	Stephan	2014	HoA	Schubert	$351,096
Koutsantonis	Tom	1997	HoA	West Torrens	$250,783
Lee	Jing	2010	LC		$240,751
Lensink	Michelle	2003	LC		$351,096
Lucas	Robert	1982	LC		$371,158
Luethen	Paula	2018	HoA	King	$200,626
Maher	Kyam	2012	LC		$321,002
Malinauskas	Peter	2015	HoA	Croydon	$351,096
Marshall	Steven	2010	HoA	Dunstan	$401,252
McBride	Nick	2018	HoA	MacKillop	$200,626
McLachlan	Andrew	2014	LC		$351,096
Michaels	Andrea	2019	HoA	Enfield	$200,626
Mullighan	Stephen	2014	HoA	Lee	$250,783
Murray 	Steve	2018	HoA	Davenport	$200,626
Ngo	Tung	2014	LC		$200,626
Odenwalder	Lee	2010	HoA	Elizabeth	$250,783
Pangallo	Frank 	2018	LC		$200,626
Parnell	Mark	2006	LC		$200,626
Patterson	Stephen	2018	HoA	Morphett	$200,626
Pederick	Adrian	2006	HoA	Hammond	$236,739
Piccolo	Tony	2006	HoA	Light	$250,783
Picton	Chris	2014	HoA	Kaurna	$250,783
Pisoni	David	2006	HoA	Unley	$351,096
Pnevmatikos	Irene	2018	LC		$200,626
Ridgway	David	2002	LC		$351,096
Sanderson	Rachel	2010	HoA	Adelaide	$351,096
Scriven	Clare	2018	LC		$250,783
Speirs	David	2014	HoA	Black	$351,096
Stephens	Terry	2002	LC		$228,714
Stinson	Jayne	2018	HoA	Badcoe	$250,783
Szakacs	Joe	2019	HoA	Cheltenham	$200,626
Tarzia	Vincent	2014	HoA	Hartley	$351,096
Teague	Josh	2018	HoA	Heysen	$228,714
Treloar	Peter	2010	HoA	Flinders	$275,861
van Holst Pelekaan	Dan	2010	HoA	Stuart	$351,096
Wade	Stephen	2006	LC		$351,096
Whetstone	Tim	2010	HoA	Chaffey	$351,096
Wingard	Corey	2014	HoA	Gibson	$351,096
Wortley	Russell	2006	LC		$200,626
Wortley	Dana	2014	HoA	Torrens	$200,626

$17.7 million and rising to pay 69 individuals who do nothing to create jobs and improve the economic situation of the population.

rev
Super Size Scraper Poster!
Posts: 3859
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 12:14 pm
Has thanked: 246 times
Been thanked: 349 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1071 Post by rev » Thu Aug 15, 2019 6:18 pm

Unemployment rate up to 6.9%.

The treasurer, whose being paid $371,158, is disappointed. But he and the rest of the government are doing nothing meaningful to bring/create new jobs. Just more talk and spin.
While they get another pay rise.
All they've done is raise the cost of living for the average South Australian, while more people lose their jobs, and many more are under employed.

He's trying to pass it off as being out of their control, blaming national and international issues that they don't have any control over. He's even blaming the US-China trade war.
“We don’t control or dictate everything. We can invest in terms of public infrastructure
LOL. Is that before or after ruling out new tram network extensions?
we can invest in terms of trying to lower the cost of doing business
Hows that? By raising the cost of living, so people spend less on other things, which hurts business, and ultimately hurts the governments bottom line?

They've hit the people with the increase in cost of living. There goes consumer confidence and a drop in spending.
Now business groups are nervous over land tax (rightly or wrongly, time will tell). But make the private sector nervous and create an uncertain atmosphere, and business investment dries up too.

There's fears globally of another major financial crisis now. We missed the so called mining boom boat last time, because by the time we started to gear up, the GFC hit and the mining industry pulled back.

rev
Super Size Scraper Poster!
Posts: 3859
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 12:14 pm
Has thanked: 246 times
Been thanked: 349 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1072 Post by rev » Sun Aug 18, 2019 7:13 pm

Something useful from the ABC for a change..

Flamable cladding audit has been underway in SA since 2017.
Adelaide Oval, nRAH and convention centre are some of buildings identified so far.
Convention Centre was confirmed last year.

Whats been done? Jack shit.

MFS are worried, want the materials tested.
But government isnt doing anything, because the centre has "sufficient" fire suppression systems.

User avatar
gnrc_louis
Gold-Member ;)
Posts: 72
Joined: Sat Nov 10, 2018 2:04 pm
Location: Grange
Has thanked: 115 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: The SA Politics Thread

#1073 Post by gnrc_louis » Sun Aug 18, 2019 8:43 pm

rev wrote:
Sun Aug 18, 2019 7:13 pm
Something useful from the ABC for a change..

Flamable cladding audit has been underway in SA since 2017.
Adelaide Oval, nRAH and convention centre are some of buildings identified so far.
Convention Centre was confirmed last year.

Whats been done? Jack shit.

MFS are worried, want the materials tested.
But government isnt doing anything, because the centre has "sufficient" fire suppression systems.
ABC News online is an excellent source of local and Australian news online. Infinitely better in particular than any of the Newscorp stable who are both awfully written and continually lack in-depth coverage of important events.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 4 guests